Prenatal screening tied to MD concerns over lawsuits: Economist

In a report from the Economist, ACOG's prenatal testing and screening guidelines are attributed at least in part to physician worries over wrongful birth litigation. See the story here:

Wanted: Perfection. Doctors try not to be sued over Down syndrome babies

Key quote:

The new guidelines may also be triggered by the surge in lawsuits. In November an ACOG survey found that 65% of obstetrician-gynecologists had reduced their practices for fear of liability claims. Clinic workers confirm that women who have imperfect babies tend to blame doctors. One nurse says her clinic can't afford the insurance to ward off the suits. 'If more tests reduce our risks, then so be it.' (emphasis mine)

What's remarkable to me is that more media attention hasn't been paid to the connection between wrongful birth lawsuits, lack of tort reform and the broadening of prenatal testing. Although ACOG has presented the guidelines as a response to requests from women, the Economist makes the point that the guidelines often are not well implemented, and many women are feeling ill-served.

From the story:

Many obstetricians are clearly overworked, with no time to offer more than suggestions and results. And although the guidelines describe these tests as options, many pregnant women are feeling badgered. Some are being asked six times or more whether they want an amniocentesis.

The economic subtext becomes more clear when you read the most recent ACOG report on litigation here. Among the key findings from the 2006 ACOG survey on professional liability:

-- Almost 70% of ob-gyn survey respondents have made changes to their practice as a result of the affordability and/or availability of professional liability insurance, and 65% have made one or more changes to their practice as a result of the risk or fear of professional liability claims or litigation.

-- A total of 89% of respondents indicated they had at least one professional liability claim filed against them during their professional careers, or an average of 2.6 claims per ob-gyn.

-- Top lawsuit allegation made against gynecologists: delay-in or failure-to-diagnose.

In other news:

From USA Today:
A mother's view of a word that wounds: 'Retard'

From the Independent (UK):
Screening IVF embryos 'can damage birth chances'
(See the original report in the NEJM here.)
Childhood asthma gene identified by scientists

From the Guardian (UK):
Benoit son's disability questioned

From WPVI-TV in Philadelphia:
Gifts for every parent